Health News

Cost of an MRI in America? $1,080. France? $280. Why? providers 'largely charge what they can get away with'

Why does getting an MRI in the United States cost $1,080 when it only costs $280 in France? The answer comes down to how the prices are set, reports Ezra Klein for The Washington Post.

"That may sound obvious," he writes. "But it is, in fact, key to understanding one of the most pressing problems facing our economy. In 2009, Americans spent $7,960 per person on health care. Our neighbors in Canada spent $4,808. The Germans spent $4,218. The French, $3,978."

The difference in expenditures isn't linked to the idea that Americans just use more health-care services (the opposite is actually true) or that we are sicker. A 2003 study on international heath-care costs and a survey released Friday by the International Federal of Health Plans both concluded it comes down to pricing. The latest survey showed that in 22 of 23 medical services, whether that was a routine doctor visit or coronary bypass surgery, Americans paid more than other developed countries.

The difference is based on the way the pricing is set. "Other countries negotiate very aggressively with the providers and set rates that are much lower than we do," said Gerard Anderson, who was involved in the 2003 study. In Canada and Britain, prices are set by the government. In Germany and Japan, the prices are "set by providers and insurers sitting in a room and coming to an agreement, with the government stepping in to set prices if they fail," Klein reports.

Outside of Medicare and Medicaid, which are cheaper than the commercial average, "it's a free-for-all" in the U.S., Klein wriotes. "Providers largely charge what they can get away with, often offering different prices to different insurers, and an even higher price to the uninsured."

Because the customer often doesn't have choice in whether or not he or she will purchase health care ? one could be unconscious or very ill ? "sellers of health-care services in America have considerable power to set prices, and so they set them quite high," Klein reports.

Fixing the problem is fraught with complication, Klein writes, because "centralized bargaining cuts across the grain of America's skepticism of government solutions." The prices are also set by very powerful industries. The federal health care reform law is not expected to fix the issue, Klein writes, though might spread awareness since there are provisions to expand transparency; hospitals will have to publish their prices, for example. "But this is, for the most part, a fight the bill ducked, which is part of the reason that even its most committed defenders don't think we'll be paying anything like what they're paying in other countries anytime soon," Klein write. (Read more)

- The Price For Health Care Could Be Right, If It's Known
By Molly Burchett Kentucky Health News People often shop around and compare prices when making a large purchase, and some consumer advocates, employers and health plans are pushing for price transparency in health care so it's easier for consumers...

- Prescribing Antibiotics For Viral Infections Must Stop; Overuse Of Antibiotics Causes Antibiotic-resistant 'superbugs'
Bronchitis is a viral infection, and antibiotics are not effective for treating viral infections. Doctors know this, yet they continue to prescribe antibiotics to patients with bronchitis and other viral infections anyway, Ezra Klein reports on his new...

- Feds Allow People Whose Health Plans Were Canceled, And Haven't Gotten A New One, To Keep Old One Or Get Catastrophic Plan
If you were among the 280,000 or so Kentuckians whose health plan didn't meet the requirements of the federal health-reform law, and you haven't enrolled in a qualified plan, you will be able to keep your old plan for a while, or buy a cheap,...

- Bill Clinton Says Obama Should Keep Promise On Insurance, But Knows That Won't Work, Washington Post Writer Says
Former president Bill Clinton's recent statement that President Obama should change the health-reform law to keep his promise that people who liked their health-insurance plans could keep them or ironic because "He's the reason Obama made the...

- Forums Set To Explain State Insurance Exchange And Its New Opportunities For Coverage, Little Known To Most Who Will Be Eligible
By Tara Kaprowy Kentucky Health News Now that Gov. Steve Beshear has issued the order to create a state health insurance exchange, the state is scheduling public forums to explain it. Rachel Klein, the executive director of Enroll America, said...

Health News