States Take Steps to Improve Oversight and Consumer Engagement
Health News

States Take Steps to Improve Oversight and Consumer Engagement


In the past few months, several states have taken dramatic steps to strengthen their rate review authority, protect consumers, and call out insurers on excessive rate increases. For example, earlier this year, California health insurers announced planned rate increases that would have driven premium costs up as much as 87 percent for some individuals. But in the face of increasing insurer profits, Insurance Commissioner Dave Jones elicited promises from California?s major health insurers that they would decrease and delay implementing proposed rate increases until the state had a chance to evaluate the accuracy of the insurers? filing. This week, Consumer Watchdog released a report indicating state reviews of insurer rate increases found erroneous math and unsupported actuarial assumptions in rate filings submitted by health insurers. California legislators are moving legislation to give the insurance commissioner explicit authority to disapprove of or reduce proposed premium increases through the state Assembly.

And in New Mexico, the state?s Republican Governor recently signed into law a bill that enhances the state?s rate review authority. The new law includes strong provisions encouraging public participation by establishing a thirty day public comment period on proposed rate increases and requiring insurers to notify policyholders of any possible increase in their premium rate before the increase can be implemented. The statute further gives policyholders the right to request a public hearing on rate increases that the Insurance Superintendent has approved.

Affordable Care Act Mandates Rate Review
The Affordable Care Act requires an annual review of unreasonable health insurance premium increases. Federal regulations, soon to be finalized, outline the process through which the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), together with state regulators, will review and evaluate health insurance premium rate increases.


While several states currently have review processes requiring a comprehensive evaluation of proposed rate increases before insurers may charge consumers and businesses more for their premiums, other states are using the new federal rate review requirement to expand consumer protections. In February, HHS announced $200 million worth of federal grant money available to states to help them strengthen their rate review processes and states will finalize their application for this money this summer.

Together with their Insurance Departments, and independently, state consumer health advocates are making tremendous progress toward protecting consumers from unreasonably high insurance premium increase. At the end of this blog post you will find new resources Community Catalyst has developed to assist states in advocating for stronger rate review laws.

State Advocates are Helping to Improve Rate Review Processes
State consumer health advocates all over the country are taking the lead to guide their states toward revising and implementing stronger rate review laws. For example, in Pennsylvania, the PA Health Access Network is developing an online petition that they intend to use to encourage their insurance commissioner to hold public hearings on proposed rate increases, giving consumers and policyholders the opportunity to provide input on rate increases.


Advocates with Illinois? Campaign for Better Health Care are supporting legislation that would give their insurance commissioner authority to disapprove or reduce proposed premium rate increases. Recent data released by the Illinois Department of Insurance shows that while insurance premium rates have increased 181 percent since 2005 for individuals and families in Illinois, the top five insurers brought in more than $28 billion in profits in 2010 alone.

And in Ohio, advocates at UHCAN Ohio are in the research phase of their campaign to improve the state?s rate review process, enhance transparency and consumer involvement as a means to protect individuals, families, and small businesses from rising health insurance costs. These advocates are in communication with officials at the Ohio Department of Insurance to better understand the current rate review process and gather data about increasing premium rates.

While we provide three examples here of state advocates working to strengthen their states? rate review laws and two states where reform is on the horizon, many other states are progressing toward stronger, consumer protective rate review processes or currently have robust laws on the books.

Tools for States to Engage in Rate Review Reform
Because most states will continue to oversee health insurance premium rate increases in their markets, Community Catalyst has designed a toolkit to assist state advocates in evaluating their state?s current rate review process and to develop advocacy resources supporting stronger rate review laws. Use the general fact sheet to explain rate review to policymakers and community organizers. The state-specific template is a guide to asking the right questions and gathering the right information and data to demonstrate the critical need for enhanced rate review authority in your state.


Sarah Blumenthal
Community Catalyst (originally posted on Health Policy Hub)




- Feds Give Ky. $3 Million To Hold Health Insurers Accountable
Kentucky will receive more than $3.2 million in federal grants to help state officials track health-insurance premium increases and make insurers more accountable. The funds are part of guidelines set forth in the Patient Protection and Affordable Care...

- One Step Closer To Knowing - Doi Issues Qhp Guidance
Under the Affordable Care Act, one of the new options for individuals and small businesses to buy health insurance for themselves and their employees in 2014 will be the Illinois health insurance exchange or "marketplace."  On March 29, 2013, the...

- States Taking The Lead In Strengthening Consumer Protection
Recently, five more States strengthened their laws protecting consumers in disputes with their health insurance plans. The District of Columbia, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, Ohio and Wisconsin have bolstered their laws surrounding the part of the appeals...

- Effective Exchange Key To Lower Health Insurance Costs For Illinois Families
It?s hard not to notice the out-of-control health insurance cost increases in recent years. Three out of every four individual-market policyholders saw a premium increase from early 2009 to early 2010.  Small businesses are particularly hard hit....

- America?s Health Care Law: Providing Security And Opportunity For All
It's been a year since the historic vote that made the Affordable Care Act (ACA) a law, putting America on the path towards a system of quality, affordable health care for all. We have a lot to celebrate as we continue to implement and enforce our...



Health News








.